SCIENCE SNAPS    

READ
Photo - Why dieting makes you fat
Expert Dr Alex Johnston (The Rowett Research Institute) explores  

Does dieting make you fat?

Despite UK Government campaigns designed to persuade people to 'eat less' and 'exercise more', public health efforts to slow the rising prevalence of overweight and obesity have had limited success, with the population getting fatter at an increasing rate. Over half the UK population are now collectively classified as overweight (BMI 25 - 30) or clinically obese (BMI>30). By the year 2010, it is estimated that 25% of the UK population will be obese. It is no longer ' the norm' to be normal weight !

There are many and complex reasons why this is happening, but it's true that the majority of people who lose weight, will subsequently regain the lost weight. There are different physiological and psychological reasons why thus may be. For example, when we lose weight, our basal metabolic rate (BMR) will decrease. Basal metabolic rate can be considered to be simply the minimum amount of energy the body requires at rest, to keep the body alive. Metabolic rate decreases because it is related to the actual amount of body tissue; more specifically the amount of muscle and lesser how much fat in the body. So as you lose weight, you have less body tissue and consequently a lower metabolism. Thus, less energy required by the body at rest. If after weight loss you go back to eating exactly what you did before you started dieting, you will simply regain back the lost weight.

In theory, achieving weight loss is simple, consume less calories than you expend. But the sad reality is that we live in an 'obesogenic' environment, which promotes weight gain.Work at the Rowett aims to understand more about what goes on inside the body and how people feel during dieting, so we can understand how diets work and develop novel dietary strategies to promote weight loss and longer term weight maintenance. However, a final word - prevention is always better than cure, so keep an eye on the scales!

LISTENListen to the SCIENCE SNAP from Sun 20th March
DISCOVERAsk the Expert
DISCOVERExplore this topic further:

 

 


Dr Alex Johnstone holding examples of meals served-up to volunteers participating in her latest study


Dr Alex Johnstone with celebrity volunteer Cameron Stout (winner of Big Brother 2003) at end of study during which Cameron lost just under two stones in weight.

EXPERT PROFILE
Photo of Dr Alex Johnston from the Rowett Research Institute

Dr Alex Johnston

The Rowett Research Institute

This is the time of year that people start a New Year’s resolution to lose weight. With over half of the Scottish population collectively overweight or normal weight, there are a lot of people needing help with body weight control. I hope my research will help them. I am a nutritional research scientist at the Rowett Research Institute and over the past 10 years, I have developed my expertise in obesity and weight loss. I run my own research programme at the Human Nutrition Unit, investigating prevention and treatment of human obesity. Whenever I tell people what my work involves, they always want to know the magic way to lose weight! I’m afraid there is no simple answer! However, my current research programme has received intense media interest, being linked to the ‘Atkins diet’. The apparent popularity for the high protein-low carbohydrate, ketogenic weight loss diet, such as that advocated for many years by Dr Robert Atkins in his book, ‘New Diet Revolution’, is the apparent ability to eat as much as you want and still lose weight. The big question is how does this diet regime work? There are possible physiological and psychological reasons why this high protein-low carbohydrate (HPLC) regime is popular. However, despite its widespread use, and many anecdotal reports, there is a lack of scientifically proven explanations why this regime works. This is what I am doing at the Rowett. Once we have an understanding what key components promote weight loss, then we can develop healthier, longer-term weight reduction strategies.

In my time at the Rowett, I have had hundred of volunteers on studies. I have been criticised by some patients because I am not obese, that I don’t know what it feels like. However, other subjects say that I practice what I preach. I’ve heard lots of different stories as to why they are overweight. Some of the popular ones include, “I’ve got big bones”; “I only have to look at a cream cake to gain weight”; ‘It’s all muscle – muscle is heavier than fat”. Fortunately, I have the specialised equipment to measure all these parameters and can therefore give the hard truth that weight gain occurs when energy in exceeds energy output. I have sophisticated equipment to measure body composition; I can measure psychological parameters, and metabolism and physiology. It’s like looking into a body to find the answers. However, some anecdotal stories that I hear are true, like fatigue during dieting and weight re-gain after weight loss.

When volunteers come to the Unit for the first time, many of them are nervous, not knowing what to expect. I rarely wear a white coat and have a down to earth, friendly approach to nutrition. My opinion is that we should look at obesity as a three-stage problem (i) prevention is better than cure, (ii) getting the weight off to improve health and (iii) helping people to avoid weight re-gain. We need to recognise that different regimes are required by different people, and that these three stages need different intervention strategies to achieve success. Ultimately, I would like to extend my research into the Primary care setting, away from just the laboratory setting at the Rowett.

There is never a dull day at the Rowett, because my job is varied and exciting! I could be designing new diets, taking blood samples or in my office, writing. These type of studies are hard work, with lots of early mornings and weekend work, but I gain great satisfaction at the end of a study when subjects lose weight and tell me how much better they feel.